Bat suggestion for strong forehand and limited backhand

Table Tennis Equipment

Last updated 1 month ago

Tanmoy Sengupta

Tanmoy Sengupta Asked 5 years ago

Hello,

I have been playing TT for close to last 2 years, both in office and club. I also got training on weekends from a local coach for a few months. I started with a premade bat (GKI Kungfu DX) which is very decent for beginners to learn strokes and spin. I have so far developed very good forehand topspin, smash, block and push, but my backhand is still not aggressive. I rely more on drives, push, block and sometimes punch blocks on my BH (cannot loop or topspin).

Last year I assembled my first custom bat, with Tibhar Carbon Shot blade, Donic Coppa JO Gold rubber on forehand and Friendship 729-08 rubber on backhand. However, the setup seemed to be too fast and lacking control for my skill level, not to mention it is quite heavy too. The dwell time seems to be very less, particularly on the FH side and due to this, pushes often goes long or out of table and in general lot of shots tend to miss the table unless I can control them well. Lifting heavy backspin balls with slow spinny topspin is also difficult. Though I must say the shots are much more powerful, speedy and difficult to return when they land on tables.

Anyway, frustrated with the lack of control in my custom bat, I went back to my premade bat while obviously sacrificing the speed and power. Now I am again looking forward to take my game to the next level and want to try out a faster bat with good control.

1) Could you please tell me which one is the reason for lack of control in my existing custom bat - is it the carbon blade (Tibhar Carbon Shot) or the fast rubber (Donic Coppa JO Gold)? Or is it both?
2) I was wondering if I should go for a totally new combination of custom bat which provides good control and decent speed (e.g. Allround wooden blade and Mark V rubbers) or should I keep the existing carbon blade and replace the rubbers with slower rubber or may be keep existing rubbers and replace the carbon blade with slower one-ply wooden blade? I am totally confused which option will give the best of both worlds (speed and control).
3) I recently played with a friend's custom bat with Joola Carbon blade with Mark V Max rubbers on both sides. Mind that it is not a carbon blade per se, but basically a one ply wooden blade with carbon coating (or something of that sort). My forehand topspins and smashes were amazing with this bat, but pushes were again going long and it a bit faster for my backhand. Will it be a wise choice if I switch to this blade with a lower thickness Mark V (1.8-2 mm on FH and 1.5-1.8 on BH) to gain the desired control and speed?
4) Given my BH style with no looping, do you think I should consider short pimples or antispin rubber? I have no experience with either of them. Or should I just use a controlled inverted rubber of lower thickness on the BH?


Alois Rosario

Alois Rosario Answered 5 years ago

Hi Tanmoy,

Choosing a bat that is appropriate can be confusing because of the thousands of choices out there.

I would go for a control blade with Mark V rubbers as your next step.  Probably 2mm rubber is better than Max.

We have the PingSkills Touch with Mark V as an example of what we would recommend.


Notify me of updates
Add to Favourites
Back to Questions

Thoughts on this question

Tanmoy Sengupta

Tanmoy Sengupta Posted 5 years ago

Thanks for your valuable inputs, Alois. Any suggestion about a non-expensive control bade? How do Stiga Allround Classic and Butterfly Jonyer H-II compare in this regard? Which one do you suggest? Also, will you recommend Joola Carbon, given that it is not really a carbon blade per se?


Alois Rosario

Alois Rosario from PingSkills Posted 5 years ago

I like both of the first two bats.  If I had to choose for myself I would choose the Jonyer blade.  Don't know much about the Joola carbon.


Tushar Verma

Tushar Verma Posted 5 years ago

Joola Carbon is a bit slow blade compared to any other carbon blade but faster than all wood blade (ALL+  OFF-). Good for learning strokes like smash, loops or drive. My club mate use this blade with Mark V max. 


Tanmoy Sengupta

Tanmoy Sengupta Posted 5 years ago

Thanks, Alois and Tushar.

I am not able to find Mark V rubbers other than Max in my locality or online (I am from India). Any idea where can I find Mark V 1.8 or 2 mm in India?


Tushar Verma

Tushar Verma Posted 5 years ago

Actually it is difficult to find suitable rubber in India because their are limited rubbers available, I am also from India and it was hard to find suitable rubber for me. You can order Mark V from

www.megaspin.net

or

www.amazon.com (not amazon.in)


Sujeet Kalsekar

Sujeet Kalsekar Posted 1 month ago

The tibhar carbon shot is a very fast blade .Go for an all wood allround ply with Mark V rubbers on both sides .It will also give you heavy spin .Try the butterfly primorac all wood with yasaka mark V rubbers .



Become a free member to post a comment about this question.